Supreme Court strikes down redrawn North Carolina districts as unconstitutional racial gerrymanders

Voters in those districts sued, claiming the lawmakers had intentionally reduced African American voting power elsewhere in the state.

In recent years, the Supreme Court has ruled for civil rights groups and black voters in challenges to political districts in Alabama, North Carolina and Virginia.

"This is a watershed moment in the fight to end racial gerrymandering", stated Eric H. Holder Jr., chairman of the National Democratic Redistricting Committee.

Congressional Districts 1 and 12 were deemed to be unconstitutional, and the areas which now contain two HBCUs - North Carolina Central University and Johnson C. Smith University, will remain redrawn to address racial inequities.

In North Carolina, both districts have since been redrawn and the state conducted elections under the new congressional map in 2016. Now legal analysts say that the decision has thrown the door wide open for more lawsuits of partisan congressional district lines.

In Monday's opinion, Kagan also wrote: "The Constitution entrusts states with the job of designing congressional districts". There are, roughly, two types of gerrymandering that come before the court: Gerrymandering by political party, and gerrymandering by race.

The court's decision centered on two congressional districts that previously contained a substantial percentage of African-American voters, but not a majority. At the same time, race can't be the predominant factor without very strong reasons, under a series of high court decisions.

The federal district court had struck down the congressional districts, specifically the 1 and 12, because there were too many black voters in them, causing the other districts to not have enough to provide any influence.

Kagan, along with liberal Justices Ginsberg, Sotomayor and Breyer, plus conservative Justice Clarence Thomas, found race was the factor. Justice Anthony Kennedy, usually the swing vote in the court, was in dissent, along with Justice Samuel A. Alito Jr. and Chief Justice John G. Roberts Jr.

Justice Neil Gorsuch, who had not yet joined the court when arguments in the case were heard in December, did not participate in the ruling. It argued the Republicans who controlled the redistricting process wanted to make surrounding districts safer for GOP candidates.

These two districts were drawn in 2016 after the Fourth Circuit Court of Appeals ruled Republicans had previously drawn congressional districts for the same objective, along racial lines.

As for the 12th District, the court said the evidence offered at trial, including live witness testimony, adequately supports the conclusion that race, not politics, accounted for the district's reconfiguration. "It is fact-specific, and there's a lot politically riding on these decisions, and sometimes taking your chance at the Supreme Court can be important".

States reconsider districts following each census, and the endeavor is a political football.

It's the latest case where justices ruled against race-based redistricting, even after tossing many protections for minority voters. To ensure compliance with the VRA, North Carolina asserted, it had drawn both districts to be majority black. The state voted in new districts in the 2016 elections, with Republicans maintaining their 10-3 advantage in the new districts. The state's Republican legislative leadership had asked the Supreme Court to get involved, but the Democratic governor and attorney general said they did not want to defend the law.

"North Carolina voters deserve a level playing field and fair elections, and I'm glad the Supreme Court agrees", North Carolina Gov. Roy Cooper, a Democrat, said.

The Supreme Court refused to consider reinstating the 2013 North Carolina voting law that discriminated against African American voters, according to a lower court ruling.

In Cooper, North Carolina's defense of CD 1 was all about question 2. Some of you have even followed through with subscriptions, which is especially gratifying.

Related Articles

  • Assange expresses readiness for dialogue with UK, US

    Assange expresses readiness for dialogue with UK, US

    The London Metropolitan Police , however, made it clear in a statement that there was an outstanding arrest warrant for Assange. Assange's lawyer, Per E Samuelsson, told Swedish Radio the decision was "a total victory" for his client.

    Bilic confirms West Ham deal completed, admits defender could leave

    West Ham have recently been linked in media reports with City striker Iheanacho and full-back Zabaleta. The 18-year-old was given a new three-and-a-half year deal at West Ham earlier this season .
    Cricket Legend Meets PM Modi Ahead Of Movie Release

    Cricket Legend Meets PM Modi Ahead Of Movie Release

    The film has already been declared tax-free in Kerala and Chhattisgarh. Produced by Ravi Bhagchandka of 200NotOut and Dr.
  • David Beckham's acting skills in King Arthur trailer leave fans 'cringing'

    David Beckham's acting skills in King Arthur trailer leave fans 'cringing'

    Needless to say, we are absolutely thrilled at the prospect of a musical done in that high energy, frenetic Ritchie style. But when a new trailer and clips from the film were released this week some were unimpressed by Beckham's acting skills.

    PC Version of Destiny 2 Will Be Available through Blizzard's Battle.net

    Destiny 2 has been scheduled for release on September 8-but, as it turns out, that is only for the console versions of the game. But of course we'll reserve judgement until we've seen the whole game in action - and gotten a chance to play it for a while.
    Japan approves bill on emperor's abdication

    Japan approves bill on emperor's abdication

    But there is no provision under the existing law for him to abdicate and be succeeded by Crown Prince Naruhito. The legislation for Akihito's case was needed because the Imperial House Law does not provide for abdication.
  • Mortgage rates retreat amid political turmoil in Washington

    Mortgage rates retreat amid political turmoil in Washington

    Only small changes have been noted to 10-year Treasury yields , which often mirror mortgage rate trends. The 5/1 ARM interest rates at PHH Mortgage are available starting at 3.310% and an April of 3.853%.
    Tom Hardy to Star in 'Spider-Man' Spinoff 'Venom'

    Tom Hardy to Star in 'Spider-Man' Spinoff 'Venom'

    Though he mainly is a villain for Spider-Man, seen in Sam Rami's 'Spider-Man 3', the character is known to also be an anti-hero. With Spidey himself now in the hands of Disney's Marvel, Sony is looking to expand the Spider-Man #franchise into new territory.

    Moon urges both talks and sanctions to rein in N Korea

    Moon has previously expressed ambivalence over the THAAD system and told Xi he was "well aware" of Chinese concerns about it. While taking the oath of office Wednesday, Moon said he's open to visiting North Korea under the right conditions.
  • Rouhani re-elected as Iran's 12th President with thumping majority

    Rouhani re-elected as Iran's 12th President with thumping majority

    His administration said it put Iran "on notice" in February after issuing a series of sanctions following ballistic missile tests. Iran says incumbent President Hassan Rouhani is ahead of his nearest competitor in an initial count of votes in the election.
    'Twin Peaks' is BACK to confuse and confound

    'Twin Peaks' is BACK to confuse and confound

    The show captured the minds of viewers over two (tbh uneven) series and one dastardly prequel film in the early 1990s. Check into the Twin Peaks refresher ahead of Sunday's premiere to get caught up on all the important details.

    Kildare South TD Martin Heydon pays tribute to retiring Taoiseach Enda Kenny

    Kenny tweeted a statement as that meeting began, confirming his plans, ahead of the news being leaked in other ways. Kenny was due to step down at midnight to become acting party leader until a successor is chosen.