TapForMobile

Court overturns former NY assembly speaker Sheldon Silver's corruption conviction


A federal appeals court has overturned the corruption conviction of former New York Assembly Speaker Sheldon Silver, citing in its Thursday decision a U.S. Supreme Court ruling from past year that raised the standards prosecutors must use when they accuse public officials of wrongdoing.

In November 2015, the 73-year-old politician was found guilty of two counts of honest services wire fraud, two counts of honest services mail fraud, two counts of extortion under color of official right and one count of engaging in illegal monetary transactions. The ruling clarified how juries should be instructed to view "an official act" in a federal bribery case.

The appeals court found that the trial judge's jury instructions should have included that definition.

Silver received two prison terms: 12 years for six criminal counts against him and 10 years on the seventh, to run concurrently.

In one alleged scheme, Silver performed favors for a doctor seeking research funding in exchange for the doctor's referral of mesothelioma patients to Silver's law firm. And Silver, analysts said, might have similar trouble.

Rebecca Roiphe, a professor at New York Law School, said McDonnell might make it harder for prosecutors to retry the case because of this.

New Yorkers can be angry with the Supreme Court for its McDonnell ruling, as well as Gov. Andrew Cuomo and the Legislature for failing again to strengthen state laws to better address political corruption, she said.


"While we are disappointed by the Second Circuit's decision, we respect it, and look forward to retrying the case", Kim said in a statement, noting that the appeals court said it found sufficient evidence for a conviction even under the new legal definition. Bob McDonnell, whose own corruption conviction was overturned. Silver, 2nd U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals, No. 16-1615. The question presented to us, however, is not how a jury would likely view the evidence presented by the Government. "The Supreme Court changed the law", Bharara wrote. "Silver's defense attorneys argued that this obvious corruption was simply business as usual in Albany, which the Supreme Court confirmed in McDonnell-defying the common sense of two NY juries and honest people everywhere", she said in a statement.

Kim said that although justice will be delayed, prosecutors do not expect justice to be denied.

Silver's lawyers argued during his appeal in March that prosecutors tried to charge him for carrying out legal, unofficial acts - such as setting up meetings and helping his cronies' kids land jobs.

The case against Silver was brought by Bharara, who also brought a number of corruption cases against politicians in Albany.

Silver - once considered one of the most powerful Democrats in Albany - was convicted in 2015 in connection with a kickback scheme.

Taub sued Columbia to get his $300,000-a-year job back but was sacked again in April after an appeals court sided with the university. It is a pillar of our democracy.

Related Articles

  • Tour de France: Dan Martin loses ground after two falls

    Tour de France: Dan Martin loses ground after two falls

    Earlier, Geraint Thomas of Team Sky also crashed out of the race. "I want to thank the other riders, who did not attack". Thomas had crashed on another descent much earlier in the stage and quit the Tour with a fractured collarbone.
    Cowboys LB Damien Wilson arrested on assault charges

    Cowboys LB Damien Wilson arrested on assault charges

    The 24-year-old made headlines last July when he missed the beginning of training camp after being hit in the eye by a paintball. Team spokesman Scott Agulnek said the Cowboys were gathering information and didn't have immediate comment.
    Peter Sagan disqualified from Tour de France after Stage 4 crash

    Peter Sagan disqualified from Tour de France after Stage 4 crash

    Sagan was seeking in this year's Tour to tie the record of six green jersey titles for the best sprinter of the three-week event. I don't know if I've snapped the fake ligament in or what - I'm going to go and get it looked at.
  • Joint Hurriyat issues protest programme in view of Burhan's maiden anniversary

    Joint Hurriyat issues protest programme in view of Burhan's maiden anniversary

    Its top leader based in Pakistani-controlled Kashmir, Syed Salahuddin, was recently designated as a "global terrorist" by the U.S. The official said curfew had also been imposed in Shopian town of South Kashmir and Trehgam in North Kashmir's Kupwara district.
    Mayweather vs. McGregor: Promotional tour to kick off in Los Angeles

    Mayweather vs. McGregor: Promotional tour to kick off in Los Angeles

    That doesn't mean that he's just going to be able to walk into T-Mobile Arena and expect to beat McGregor without a fight. Anyway he wants to do it, (McGregor) is gonna get whooped.
    Protesters arrested during Nathan's hot dog contest in Coney Island

    Protesters arrested during Nathan's hot dog contest in Coney Island

    In the women's competition , Mikie Sudo, 31 and weighing 126 pounds, won her fourth title in a row by eating 41 hot dogs and buns. So Chestnut and Stonie, for all their extraordinary powers, could just as easily be seen as everyday patriots.
  • Lewis Hamilton set to miss Formula 1's London live show

    Lewis Hamilton set to miss Formula 1's London live show

    The race organisers say the fee will have leapt to STG25 million ($A42 million) by 2026 - the a year ago of the current contract. We need to figure out a way for them to make more money, so either we need to create new revenue streams or re-cut the deal.
    Trump pressures Congress to move forward with healthcare reform

    Trump pressures Congress to move forward with healthcare reform

    That sequence - Trump and party leaders favored it early this year but then abandoned it - would face all but certain defeat. Now, the new Republican bill has drawn criticism from Republican party members too and that is not just from McCain.
    Wimbledon 2017: Bethanie Mattek-Sands suffers horrific leg injury

    Wimbledon 2017: Bethanie Mattek-Sands suffers horrific leg injury

    Bethanie Mattek-Sands has been rushed off to hospital, from playing a match at Wimbedon, after a horrific fall on court 17. The injury to her knee was so gruesome that she asked the medics to cover it up with a towel.
  • Mahrez furious with Leicester over Arsenal delays

    Mahrez furious with Leicester over Arsenal delays

    But more importantly he has to be committed and I think he has to show supporters, staff and players that. But if players want to go, ultimately they have contracts and they have to honour them.
    Trump says it again: MX will pay for wall

    Trump says it again: MX will pay for wall

    Trump's comment before the bilateral meeting ignited outrage across Mexico, with much of the irea trained on Nieto himself. On Friday, Trump said they are making "very good progress" on "negotiating NAFTA and some other things with Mexico".
    Halo 5 Confirmed To Get True 4K Support For Xbox One X

    Halo 5 Confirmed To Get True 4K Support For Xbox One X

    The team also revealed that four more Halo games will be coming to the Xbox One backward compatibility program later in the year. The game wasn't announced for Xbox One X support even though nearly every other major first party game was confirmed to get it.

Comments